Tuesday, November 25, 2014

Jacoby and Nitta 2012


Jacoby, Daniel F., and Keith Nitta. 2011. "The Bellevue Teachers Strike and Its Implications for the Future of Postindustrial Reform Unionism." Educational Policy: 533-563


  • Reform unionism: moving away from adversarial relationships, by breaking down barriers between workers and managers, including "management prerogatives" (536)
    • in teaching this idea meant organizing around education quality, and professionalism whereby the union would police its own standards (537)
    • teachers unions used this to immunize themselves against the critiques of industrial unionism and its adversarialness (537)
    • reform teacher unions redefine management and labr such that teachers are uderstood as porfessionals whose particiaption in school governance is essential (538)
    • but postindsutrial unionism might just be a panopticon, says some critical theorists (539)
  • What they found in Bellevue was that teachers started focusing/bargaining over wages specifically becaues they had no say in teh curriculum, or lost their say there, and without that what's left to bargain over? (547)
    • union went from helping promote, taking responsibility for student achievement to demanding a greater role for teachers' invovlement...change from helpful to a bit more advesarial in doing so (553-554)

No comments:

Post a Comment